Showing posts with label Maine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Maine. Show all posts

Monday, February 16, 2015

Taxing Nonprofits

As we begin the budget debate here in Maine Governor LePage has put out a plan to gradually reduce the income tax by, among other things, allowing communities to levy the  property tax on    large nonprofits and eliminating revenue sharing to communities.  What is probably ideological is his desire to reduce income tax in favor of an increased sales, renamed consumption tax, and a return to more taxing at the local level.  What is probably not an ideological, but pragmatic, is the search for new goods, services, and now properties to tax. 

For both nonprofits and local communities this raises all sorts of implications.  As it is now, some nonprofits pay sales taxes when they purchase goods, others do not.  Maine exempts large swaths of nonprofits form paying sales tax, primarily in the heath area, hospitals and clinics, but not educational health organizations;  churches; schools; and nonprofit fire departments, for example.  Nonprofits also pay property taxes and income taxes on businesses in which they make a profit.  Usually these businesses are established to feed back funds into the nonprofit and are common in healthcare.   The medical lab of Eastern Maine Healthcare is for profit to support the hospital as a whole.

Nonprofits will want to defend themselves, by citing aggregate services they provide to the economy, jobs they provide and services they provide that government does not have to provide.  This will not be enough.  This argument could be made by for profits as well, and libertarians would go so far as to say that businesses should not be taxed at all because they are the job creators.  Most of us, however, are more pragmatic and see it as necessary to levy taxes on businesses and some nonprofits.

The difference has to be in how nonprofits convey what they do with greater transparency.  As a member of my community's warrant committee, each year we ask nonprofits who are requesting a donation from the town to provide basic financial figures and the number of persons served and any subsidies to community members.

This should not be hard to find in the days of the internet, yet it often is.  In fact, many nonprofits don't even identify themselves as nonprofit on their websites.  In a study I conducted of Indiana nonprofit websites (excluding hospitals, but not clinics), a little over half,  53%, identified  themselves as a nonprofit by using such words as nonprofit, non-profit, not-for-profit, nonprofit, charity, 501c3 (an IRS identification of a nonprofit), 990 (the form that nonprofits must send to the IRS), or tax-exempt. 

Hospitals have one more obligation: they must provide a community benefit form, to the public and IRS, in order to retain their nonprofit status.  Community benefits include subsidized health care, unreimbursed costs, and patient and community health education.  These reports may not be enough if we can't easily distinguish whether a hospital is for profit or nonprofit.  Educational institutions are under no such similar obligation and we often call these large institutions, private, think of Bates, Bowdoin, and Colby, to distinguish them from our state educational institutions.  They, too, will need to be more transparent in what community benefits they provide in lieu of property taxes. 


I will discuss nonprofit transparency further in a coming blog.

Taxing Nonprofits

As we begin the budget debate here in Maine Governor LePage has put out a plan to gradually reduce the income tax by, among other things, allowing communities to levy the  property tax on    large nonprofits and eliminating revenue sharing to communities.  What is probably ideological is his desire to reduce income tax in favor of an increased sales, renamed consumption tax, and a return to more taxing at the local level.  What is probably not an ideological, but pragmatic, is the search for new goods, services, and now properties to tax. 

For both nonprofits and local communities this raises all sorts of implications.  As it is now, some nonprofits pay sales taxes when they purchase goods, others do not.  Maine exempts large swaths of nonprofits form paying sales tax, primarily in the heath area, hospitals and clinics, but not educational health organizations;  churches; schools; and nonprofit fire departments, for example.  Nonprofits also pay property taxes and income taxes on businesses in which they make a profit.  Usually these businesses are established to feed back funds into the nonprofit and are common in healthcare.   The medical lab of Eastern Maine Healthcare is for profit to support the hospital as a whole.

Nonprofits will want to defend themselves, by citing aggregate services they provide to the economy, jobs they provide and services they provide that government does not have to provide.  This will not be enough.  This argument could be made by for profits as well, and libertarians would go so far as to say that businesses should not be taxed at all because they are the job creators.  Most of us, however, are more pragmatic and see it as necessary to levy taxes on businesses and some nonprofits.

The difference has to be in how nonprofits convey what they do with greater transparency.  As a member of my community's warrant committee, each year we ask nonprofits who are requesting a donation from the town to provide basic financial figures and the number of persons served and any subsidies to community members.

This should not be hard to find in the days of the internet, yet it often is.  In fact, many nonprofits don't even identify themselves as nonprofit on their websites.  In a study I conducted of Indiana nonprofit websites (excluding hospitals, but not clinics), a little over half,  53%, identified  themselves as a nonprofit by using such words as nonprofit, non-profit, not-for-profit, nonprofit, charity, 501c3 (an IRS identification of a nonprofit), 990 (the form that nonprofits must send to the IRS), or tax-exempt. 

Hospitals have one more obligation: they must provide a community benefit form, to the public and IRS, in order to retain their nonprofit status.  Community benefits include subsidized health care, unreimbursed costs, and patient and community health education.  These reports may not be enough if we can't easily distinguish whether a hospital is for profit or nonprofit.  Educational institutions are under no such similar obligation and we often call these large institutions, private, think of Bates, Bowdoin, and Colby, to distinguish them from our state educational institutions.  They, too, will need to be more transparent in what community benefits they provide in lieu of property taxes. 


I will discuss nonprofit transparency further in a coming blog.

Tuesday, December 2, 2014

The New Age Friendly Maine

The New Age Friendly Maine

One of my friends who is a new mother was commenting on the difficulty of carrying all the equipment around with her, particularly that ubiquitous hard baby bucket.  She wished that there were hooks on the wall so that she didn’t have to put the bucket on the floor, just as there are railings along some walls for those who are unsteady on their feet. 

As many bemoan the aging of the population in Maine and cry for economic development to keep or bring young people to the state, some communities are embracing the reality to create a better place to live for all of us, whether old or young.  That’s the case with Bowdoinham where I talked with town manager William Post and the new coordinator for Older Adult Services, Patricia Oh, about creating an age friendly community.  As Bowdoinham created its most recent comprehensive plan, it learned what other communities have learned that the community was aging.  Rather than looking at the negative, with the help of a needs’ assessment carried out by Patricia Oh, Bowdoinham created a dynamic advisory committee, all 60 and over, to develop activities for seniors but also to create more inclusive community events that incorporated activities for seniors.  This year’s Celebrate Bowdoinham included events for the whole family, but following the recommendations of the Advisory Committee increased the number of handicapped parking areas, added a drop off area closer to events, added seating areas, and expanded activities specifically for older residents, including bingo, a shared memory board, a gaming table (cribbage and QWIRKL), a trivia contest, and extra space for socialization under a tent.

Towns with a recreation center, a Y, or a town rec program can do the same. That is the social aspect. 

Bowdoinham wants to be more than a place where social activities are present for older adults. It wants to make the community to be a place for all people, not only in terms of the social environment but also the physical environment.  Anyone who has watched a toddler or older person, a woman in heels, or a person navigating a wheel chair knows the perils of uneven pavement.  That’s part of making the physical environment age friendly. 

Bowdoinham has become the first designated community in Maine to be included in the WHO Global Network of Age-friendly Cities and Communities.  To have this designation, Bowdoinham is constantly examining common sense needs from pedestrian friendly intersections and other transportation needs, to civic participation and inclusion, to ways to communicate with all population groups. What Bowdoinham has found is a wealth of untapped institutional memory to help the community grow.

Though certainly we need to have new jobs, improving the quality of life, whether for our young people, older people, or those somewhere in the middle, will do a lot to keep people in Maine and attract others.


If you want to learn more, you can go to Bowdoinham’s website, Advisory Committee on Aging  and to the World HealthOrganization Age Friendly checklist   Other communities are actively pursuing a senior friendly environment such as Ellsworth and Bar Harbor. As Michelle Beal, City Manager of Ellsworth said in a recent Ellsworth American story, helping seniors makes sense. They don't cost a lot for the city and meeting their needs is an economic development opportunity.

Tuesday, May 21, 2013

Whither Democracy


Whither democracy? Are town meetings a vestige of the past?
We are fortunate to live in New England where town citizens have a degree of control over the local taxes they pay that is unprecedented in other parts of the country.  We decide how much we will be taxed in town meeting.  A group of citizens is appointed by our elected town councilors or select board to serve on warrant committees to review proposed budgets for our communities, make recommendations to our elected officials and to the greater public at town meeting.  This is a position held seriously as a component of New England democracy.  Those who serve attain greater insight into how monies are used, how monies are saved, and how their respective communities plan for future long term needs. Warrant committee members get to know department directors as they explain details of budgets.  Warrant committees also meet with the local school boards, school principals to better understand school budgets and encourage savings.
As Island warrant committees meet they soon learn structural constraints on what the committees can do. The county portion is fixed; so too is the high school budget.  An irony of the reorganization of our schools is that we were fortunate enough to retain the ability on the island to choose elected boards for our individual schools, but we limited our ability to share resources to save money.  Even though the warrant committees are unable to make changes to the county budget, the process for determining that budget is indeed democratic.  The County Budget Committee is composed of citizens and elected officials from throughout the county.  When it makes a recommendations by at least a 2/3rds vote, the county commissioners may override the recommendations only by a unanimous vote of the three Hancock County Commissioners. 
As crowds have thinned in our Island town meetings, some have openly wondered in the value of a town meeting given these constraints.  They should wonder even more considering a tiny change in wording of the warrants in Southwest Harbor.  At the town meeting citizens discovered that no longer could the Warrant Committee recommend citizens appropriate a higher amount than the Select Board. A recommendation by the Warrant Committee to appropriate $25,000 more for capital improvements clearly printed in the annual report was for naught.  The wording of all the warrants had been changed since last year to prohibit any spending over and above what was specifically stated in the warrant by the select board.  Many warrants in Maine read something like, "To see what sum the Town will vote…"  In the new Southwest Harbor warrants, the amount is specifically stated.  This means that once the selectmen make a decision in January during their meetings, the town meeting becomes a plebiscite.  What if you voted no?  It's true someone on the floor could amend the warrant to a lower amount but not to a higher amount to be raised.  Now it may be a little bit odd to be in a position to want to raise more revenues--that is raise your own taxes, but at times we have done just that.  Southwest Harbor citizens decided to appropriate more money for the library than recommended by the Select Board and the Warrant Committee one year.  I bet other towns on the island have done so as well. 
Many years ago the Select Board members would make a recommendation and then the Warrant Committee would do so and move the question.  Now the Select Board makes a recommendation after the warrant committee and moves the question.  It is a very subtle difference.  The earlier way asserted more authority to the citizen committee; the newer asserts the control of the select board.  At the time I could see that either position might be argued as correct.  But the change this year is in the wrong direction.  The purpose of a warrant committees is to review and make recommendations. It is another set of eyes on the budget.  It was very likely that the Town would have agreed with the Select Board's recommendation and not the higher amount.  The Warrant Committee has applauded the work of the town manager to improve budgeting for the town and reduce the budget.  Yet if the town of Southwest Harbor continues with this wording of its warrants, and other towns adopt this approach, then it is not worth having a warrant committee nor a town meeting.  A little more of New England democracy goes by the way side.